"It never gets easier, you just go faster." - Greg Lemond
Showing posts with label Hoka. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Hoka. Show all posts

Monday, April 8, 2013

Hoka Bondi B 2 Review

By Guest Reviewer Jason Robertson

Jason's review of the Hoka Stinson Evo Low was so popular that when he bought a pair of the new Bondi 2's I pestered him for a review until he finally agreed.  Enjoy!


My Recent History with the Hokas:
     Last June I picked up a pair of Hoka One One Stinson Evo B Lows.  In my review I raved about their downhill prowess, sticky rubber traction, and the polished fit and feel.  I also questioned the outsole longevity and how would running in such a pillowy-soft shoe effect the training adaptations typically received in lower, less cushioned, more flexible shoes.
     The summer is my high volume time of the year as I am not teaching.  So I ran.  Mixing the New Balance 110’s, Brooks Pure Grit, and the Hoka Stinson B’s; I averaged 85 miles per week.  The Hokas were my long run shoe of choice.  I continued this until the peak phase for the Hell 50k in September.  I ran the Woodstock 50K and two weeks later I raced and won the Hell 50k.  I did both races in the NB 110’s.  After Hell, my hip was incredibly sore and I took October off.  During this time the Hokas became suspect to the hip injury and I shelved them.
     During November and throughout the winter months I tried several new shoes and started to mix the Hokas back in.  My hip healed up after some much needed cross-training and yoga sessions.  Finally, in February, I was 18 miles into a road run wearing the Altra Instincts.  My left calf felt as if someone had snuck up and stabbed it with a knife.  I immediately called my wife and she graciously picked me up.  Throughout the next two months I tried every shoe, stretch, and rehab technique in my inventory and nothing seemed to help.  The calf would seem ok, then boom! Injury and back to square one.  I pulled out of the 100 miler I was signed up for, but I had this awesome trip planned to the Smokey Mountains.  I utilized Running Warehouse’s return policy, sending back the Altras (both the Instincts and Superiors) and had them send me a pair of the new Hoka Bondi B 2s.


Hoka Bondi B’s
     These shoes allowed me not only to enjoy the trip, but to run much more than initially expected.  I started very cautiously, hiking the ups and jogging on the downs (there’s not much in between).  Then, toward the end of our first outing I was able to run the downhill and feel zero pain in the calf.  The next day, I ran everything that my current state of fitness would allow and no pain.  I commented to Jon several times how good these shoes felt and how good my calf was doing.  Third day, besides crossing an icy river of death, all was well.  On the fourth, I switched to the Brooks Cascadia because of some preconceived notions of mud in the upper elevations needing increased traction.  My calf spoke to me all day.  I still have no idea why the calf is good in the Bondi B’s and nothing else, but I’ll take it.  Here’s my take on the shoe

The author horsing around in his Hoka Bondi B 2's

Fit and Feel:
     The Bondi’s have a great upper.  Very thin mesh on the outer, a hexagonal structured material and then a final mesh that sits against your sock that is very comfortable.  I had over seven hours and never felt a hot spot or uneasy rubbing.  The shoe runs true to size, if not a touch over-sized.  I wear 10’s in the NB 110’s and bought a size 10 Bondi.  I could probably go for a 9.5, but with long races and foot swelling, the 10’s will be just fine.  My first run in the Stinsons did develop some chaffing around my pinky toe area.  I had nothing with the Bondi.  From the first run until now, no blister or hot spots; these uppers are top-notch.  One of our shorter outings, a 3.5 hour, had a stream crossing right off the bat.  Feet were wet the entire time and no issues. They are not over-built, but do offer enough structure for technical trail use.
     As good as the uppers feel, there does seem to be a weak spot.  I now have well over 50 hours in the Bondi.  After yesterdays trail marathon the upper around the toe box was stressed to the point that some holes were forming in the first layer of mesh.  These had not formed until yesterday and the race took place on a mountain bike course with many tight, twisty switchbacks.  I wasn’t too surprised by this and it confirmed the major weakness of this shoe.
Slight wear on both sides of the toe box

Not a Shoe with the Quickness:
     This is the major drawback with the Bondi, in my opinion.  You just don’t get a high turn-over or quick turning manners from this shoe. Think slow(er) and methodical versus light and racey.
On the first major downhill, heading back to Laurel Falls the trail was strewn about with a lot of technical debris: rocks, roots, mud, tight-twisty turns, and off cambers; I thought I was flying.  Jon came up and let me know that our 9 minute per mile pace was ok, but went shooting by in his Senses (half the weight, half the mid-sole, much higher turn-over).  I just didn’t feel safe following.  I felt very protected and could’ve ran that pace over that terrain all day, but just didn’t feel like I could handle all the technicalities any faster.  Yesterday’s trail marathon was on much smoother terrain where I could really fly on the downs, but the tight-twisties forced me to slow slightly.  
     Safety on the down hills is also where this shoe seems to shine over the Stinson.  I never felt my ankle twist or have any major deflection on the loose rock as I did with the Stinson B’s.  This did give me more confidence going into loose rock piles and slick roots.  In my opinion, I think the Bondi does a better job of absorbing the side-load impacts than does the Stinson; most likely because of mid-sole design.
Outsole design:
     Super tacky! As good as the Stinson B’s outsole and the quality of the rubber for trail use is, the Bondi trumps it.  As mentioned before, I wore the Cascadias on our last outing because we thought it would be incredibly muddy with all the snow melt.  I didn’t notice much of a difference in traction levels and was left wanting the plushness and calf soothing feel of the Bondi. Anything but algae covered river rock is traction for the Bondi.  Back in Fort Wayne this week, we had a few days of sloppy, snotty mud and while there was some slippage, I was happy with the way that this road shoe handled the mud.  Hoka could make a very nice winter running trail shoe simply by adding lugs to the rubber portions of this shoe- good stuff.
Outsoles after about 50 hours



Conclusions
The Goods:
1. Great fit and feel, the upper and sizing are spot on. All day comfort, lace ‘em up and forget.
2. Protection and midsole shape.  Inspires confidence and great for injury prone runners and recovery days.
3. Awesome outsole, holds on to multiple surfaces even though it’s marketed as a road shoe.

The Bads:
1. While very comfortable the upper is weak in some spots
2. Not a fast turner or allows for high turn-over as other lighter shoes do (12oz on the food scale)

All in all, these are allowing me to run and get back to a normal training schedule.  If you’re in the Hoka market, I would definitely look at, and try on a pair of the new Bondi B’s.  They are very useful for trail applications, high mileage outings on road, trail, mountains, ect. If you’re racing 50 miles or more, these would be great in a drop bag- the longer the race/outing the better they feel. 
  

Monday, October 8, 2012

(My) Top Ten Most Anticipated Trail Shoes of 2013


What shoes am I most excited about for the "spring" 2013 trail shoe season?  Here I rank them, 1 being the shoe I am most eager to test, with 10 still being anticipated!

I have reviews posted for a few of these shoes, including:
Asics Gel Fuji Trainer 2
Hoka One One Bondi B 2
La Sportiva Helios

1.  Salomon Sense Mantra - 6mm heel to toe drop makes this shoe seem useful over the LONG run.  6mm really seems to be my sweet spot.  At about 9 ounces, the Mantra is a touch heavier than the Sense, but it still retains many of the innovative technologies (endofit, uniquely lugged outsole, lightweight rock plate) utilized in the S-Lab series shoes.  Salomon makes the best gear on the market, and I have little doubt these shoes will last.


Sense Mantra (Photo Credit Alpenglow sports)

(Photo Credit Alpenglow sports)


2.  Pearl Izumi e:Motion Trail N1/2 - It was actually a tough contest between the Sense Mantra and the new P.I. e:Motion series.  While just about everyone has raved about these new P.I. shoes, my love of the well built Salomon gear won out.  Nonetheless, I have little doubt that Pearl will be putting out a quality product in the new e:Motion shoes.  The "dynamic offset" system is intriguing.  A strong forefoot/midfoot plant compresses the midsole, resulting in the true offset of the shoe.  After his record setting WS100 win in the P.I. N1 Trail, Tim Olson described his N1's as having a 1mm offset at a standstill, but a 4mm offset during the his footstrike, although runningwarehouse's blog states a 6mm offset.  My only concern is that this degree of estimated offset will be highly different between runners of different efficiencies and weight.  They also make a road shoe - which would be great if you really find these shoes to be perfect for you.  I personally am struggling with choosing between the N1 and N2.  Also the color schemes are badass.


N1 Trail (Photo Credit Runningwarehouse)
N2 Trail (Photo Credit Runningwarehouse)


3.  Asic Gel Fuji Trainer and Attack - I personally love Asics Shoes.  The Gel Fuji Racers have been a huge hit, which I hope encourages Asics to continue to make lightweight trail shoes.  Putting in over 1,000 miles in my Gel Fuji Racers, there were more than a few times that I wouldn't have minded a little more protection, as well as not having the bottom vents or drains.  The Gel Fuji Trainer addresses both these issues, at the cost of a little extra weight.  Interestingly, the Fuji series actually includes several other shoes that are available overseas, but not in the USA.  I've been considering a buying a pair from Wiggle, but decided to wait for the US iteration. Which is available for pre-order at both runningwarehouse and roadrunnersports!

Gel Fuji Trainer
Gel Fuji Attack
Gel Fuji Attack (Photo Credit Wiggle)
Fuji Trainer (photo credit Runningwarehouse)

Fuji Trainer outsole (photo credit Runningwarehouse)


4.  La Sportiva Anakonda - I have raced in the Sportiva Crosslite, as well as in the X-Country, and felt like the Crosslite was just too much shoe in the upper, while the X-Country wasn't quite enough in the midsole.  BOOM, La Sportiva read my mind, combined the two shoes, and created the Anakonda.  Advertised as weighing 9.5 ounces, they look to have a very lightweight upper that will drain well, and utilize the amazing rubber that is a trademark of La Sportiva.  Other than that, it is rather difficult to find much more info on these shoes.  To me, the picture says it all.


(Photo Credit one50South blog)
Most similar to X-country outsole (Photo Credit Trailrunningreview)


5.  New Balance M080 - A new minimus model that seems to be under the radar, honestly, I am not even sure if these are supposed to be trail running shoes.  But they have an excellent looking, fully lugged outsole, with sticky Vibram rubber, are built on the well designed Minimus last (NL-1), and have a 4mm drop.  Having raced a 50 miler in the original MT10, I always thought that with a little more protection, and no forefoot strap, they could be perfect.  NB has made several attempts at perfecting the shoe with the MT110, MT20 (v1 and v2), and the MT1010, but small drawbacks have limited my use and/or interest in these shoes.  Hopefully NB finally nails it!


Cool suede looking upper but will it last?  (Photo Credit Runningwarehouse)
Full outsole without any holes!  (Photo Credit Runningwarehouse)




5.  Hoka One One Bondi B 2 -  I'm in the middle of a love-hate relationship with my own Bondi B's.  One of the major flaws I found with these shoes is that the upper is horribly uncomfortable.  Combine this with the fact that your feet are at the mercy of a heavy duty rather inflexible midsole and it can get to be annoying.  On the other hand, these shoes eat up nasty trail and leave the legs feeling fresh.  Updated upper on the Hoka Bondi B 2 indicates a totally new material that looks like it will be much more comfortable and lighter as well.  I have high hopes for this update, considering how much attention Hoka has recieved, I hope they continue to put out innovative new products.  I made these pics from screen shots taken from the speedgoat promo video (so please forgive my crappy computer skills), because I can't find anything out there about these guys.





6.  Salomon S-Lab Sense Ultra - The more consumer "friendly" version of the S-Lab Sense, but made to be more durable.  This is achieved by using a firmer midsole (is that a good thing? - Im not sure) as well as giving the shoe more lugs and larger lugs.  On the other hand, they're still quite pricey (180$) and heavier (8oz) so I am not sure if I will own a pair.  While I am still undecided as to if they will be the right shoe for me, I expect to see quite a few people wearing these at Ultras next year.


Black and Red color scheme - I approve (photo credit Utahoutside)


Sense Ultra Outsole (Photo Credit Sam winebaum's blog)

7.  The North Face Ultra Guide and Hypertrack Guide - I ran quite a bit in TNF Single Track Hayasa until the traction disappeared.  They had a good combination of flexibility, protection, and cushion while being light weight.  Also, all TNF shoes I have owned are incredibly comfortable, like the most comfortable.  So this has me expecting a shoe that is pleasant to wear in the ultra and hypertrack guides.  TNF is releasing/updating their trail shoes and has several other offerings coming out this spring, but I think the shoe I am most excited for is the Hypertrack version.  I'm pretty sure this is what Ian Sharman was wearing at UROC 100k, and they are bright!  Specs include an 8mm heel to toe drop, and both models weigh under 10oz.


Hypertrack guide (Photo Upprvalley.com)
Ultratrack (Photo credit Runningwarehouse)



8.  La Sportiva Helios - I really enjoy the occasional run in the Vertical K's.  However, once I hit gravel roads, or trails strewn with gravel, I start to get frustrated with myself for choosing to wear the Vert Ks.  That's because they have no rockplate.  If you catch a sharp stone in the thin area of the morphodynamic midsole, you're in for an eye opener.  That being said, they are super flexible, plenty light, have great traction, and are very fun to run downhill in.  So really all you need to do is add a rockplate.  OK YAY!  Sportiva does this with the introduction of the Helios.  It ups the weight a tad, but if you've spent time in the Vertical K, you know they are so light, a little weight for a tad more protection is no biggie.  Basic anatomy of the Vertical K is maintained, except perhaps a slightly wider platform, to increase stability.  Oh, also it looks like they have include an extra eyelet to help lock down the heel, which I think will be a nice addition.  It'll be cool to see how these shoes do over rocky trail, but I'm disappointed I will have to buy another pair of shoes so similar to a pair I already own (i.e. Vert K).  Also nice colorways.

I've since reviewed the Helios - Check it out here


Blue (photo credit irunfar)


Grey/pink Women's Helios (photo credit Trail running review)


9.  Hoka One One Rapa Nui Comp - Cool to see Hoka trying something a little different as the company continues to grow.  These are what Hoka considers a racing flat :)   Keeping with the traditional Hoka ideal, they have quite a bit of compressible midsole, a rocker-ed profile, and a 5mm heel to toe drop.  Will these be as protective as Hokas normally are?  Probably not, as they appear to have only 2/3s the stack height of a pair of Bondis.  But sometimes all that foam is overkill, so it will be interesting to see how popular these shoes are.  I found all the info for this post on the blog of Ian Corless, the host of Talk Ultra, my absolute favorite podcast. They will also feature a road version.


10.  New Balance 1210 (AKA Leadville) - Last but not least!  I'm 99% sure Anton wouldn't wear these at Leadville, but for the rest of us mortals, its great to see New Balance finally apply themselves to updating the rest of their trail shoe line.  This is achieved through the use of the new Revlite foam they have designed as well as utilizing the Phantom fit upper.  I've heard great things about the Phantom fit upper, and personally love the Revlite foam, so I think these shoes will have a solid following, especially in the midpack ultra community.  Sad to see they are spec'd at a 9mm heel to toe drop, and I wouldn't be surprised to see them move this down to 6mm in following versions.

Vibram Outsole
Not bad looking (Photo credit Runningwarehouse)


Thursday, September 13, 2012

Hoka One One 2013 Race Shoes

I'm still not 100% sold on the Hoka concept.  More like 90%.  Anyways, I think a few minor tweaks to the Bondi B could make this shoe go from good to great, in my book.  Trying to find info on the Bondi B 2 is hard as hell, but I did stumble across new "racey" shoes from Hoka due out in 2013.  Interesting...

Kinda a bummer that both these shoes look so sweet - I'll want both, and Hoka is still on the pricey side of things (if you can find even find your size). 

Check them out at the Talk Ultra site:

http://iancorless.org/2012/08/24/new-hoka-one-one/

Monday, July 16, 2012

Hoka One One Stinson B Evo Low Review

By Jason Robertson

I had been considering getting a pair of Hokas.  While I couldn't find the correct size, Jason (who is also a shoe nerd) picked up a pair of the new Stinson B Evos, and I begged him for a review.  Enjoy!
Get the name right damnit!  Minimalist shoe label from the running store.


Fit
A little narrow in the toe box.  My left foot is larger than my right and pinky toe was slightly rubbing.  I was able to change out the standard-sized, left insole for the thinner one provided-no more rubbing and nice customization.  This was the only concern I had with the fit of this shoe.  The upper has great lock-down and provides day-long comfort.  It also has a taller (more volume) and slightly more narrow fit than, say, a MT110 or the Brooks Pure Grit.  I run a size 10 in those models and have found the 10.5 in Hokas very nice, in addition to the thinner insole in my left shoe.
Accessories:  Extra insoles and laces

Traction
Traction rocks on this shoe.  You can hear it grip on pavement and the dry hard pack we’ve experienced here in Northeast Indiana this summer.  It does lack the deep lugs of a Salomon Speedcross, but I’d say the rubber is on par with the MT110 for tackiness. I felt very secure on wet, downhill corners during my outings in the Smokies and no problems on wet rock (the Brooks Pure Grit really let me down on the slick rock during our last trip so I was very cautious and was pleasantly surprised with the Stinson B Evo).  This outsole also receives high marks for self-cleaning action.
Wear resistant, very tacky Hoka outsole, very nice!

Cushion

Goes without saying…this shoe has lots of cush.  Confidence inspiring, feels like cheating, unfair advantage cush.  This shoe has allowed me, over the past month, to become a downhill bomber.   I’ve also, at the same time, been able to handle an increase in mileage as I’ve had time off from work this summer.  My legs have not had that “beat down” feeling they usually receive from such an increase into the 100 mile per week range. 

Some might say, and mentioned by Marshall Ulrich in his review of Hokas, that having so much cushion could prevent or hinder the gains (i.e. muscle breakdown-healing, ligament, joint, tendon strengthening/changing) of running in a more minimally cushioned shoe.  I do wear and run in the Minimus 00, Kinvara and the Pure Grit a few times each week and know there is benefit in low slung shoes.  I recovered from an injury 2 years ago through a process of running barefoot and utilizing minimal shoes.  Not having a serious injury since, I want to maintain my form.  The Hokas have allowed for more vigorous miles to be put in each week and I believe they have allowed some strengthening in areas that lesser cushioned shoe might not.  For instance, pounding the down hills helped strengthen my quads.  I also noticed my ankles feeling a bit worked-similar to when I do barefoot speed work on the soccer fields.  The Hokas also allow for the same cadence and running stance that I have developed with my other lower shoes.  It is interesting to note that Playmakers have a minimalist label on the box as seen in my first picture.

Lots of cushion in these bad boys
Protection
Search out the sharpest stingers on the trail.  Nothing short of a 3” nail will hurt your foot.  I totally understand why Darcy Africa (a PI sponsored runner) would opt for the Hokas at Hard Rock, even when she has Isoseeks at her disposal.  4-4.5 hour run/hikes in the Smokies had my feet begging for more. Usually after the four hour mark of running trail, especially in the Smoky Mountains, my feet start letting me know that they’re feeling the rocks, roots and uneven terrain. No matter what I stepped on, I felt no pain.  I am very excited to try these out in some fall 50 milers and next year’s mountain 100’s.
Flexibility
Next to none.  This did make my left arch sing a little (same tightness I had with the MT100/101s).  After some foam rolling on the calf, all was well.  With such a well cushioned midsole, the Hoka is a stiff shoe.  You can’t roll it up like a Nike Free.  This is just fine with me.  The stiffness actually inspires quite a bit of confidence when rolling fast on the downs and the rockered shape of the shoe allows for a nice seamless foot strike to toe off.

Likes
·        Awesome cushion and protection.  I will never again have to choose what shoe I’ll wear on a run over 3 hours…or question whether or not to bomb a downhill.
·        Great drainage.  After the several crossings we did in the Smokies, I was very impressed.  This shoe, surprisingly, drained and dried as well as a pair of 101s, which in my opinion; earned the title for the quickest drain/dry shoe.
·        Nice alternate insole/lacing options (comes with quick lace intact-laces optional, but you have to cut the quick lace in order to remove).
·        Overall fit and wear.  I plan on wearing this shoe through next summer and have no concerns about this shoes making it to 1,500 miles-seems very durable at this point. Also, the fit and drop of the shoe does not interfere with wearing my other shoes.  I simply throw on the extra cushion, no worries about a large ramp angle when switching to a more cushioned shoe. 
Dislikes
·        Weight claims.  I read from several sources that these shoes weighed in anywhere between 9 and 10.5 ounces for a men’s size 9.  The shoes I purchased, a size 10.5, weighed in at 13 1/8 ounces on my extremely accurate food scale.  This is about the weight of a pair of Cascadia 6s in the same size.  Interestingly enough, I planned to buy a pair of Cascadia 7s.  I tried on the Hokas 1st, ran around the store, ran a 5k with Scott Jurek(! Stopped in on his book tour) in a trial pair then tried on the Cascadias.  They felt very flat and unresponsive comparatively.  I dropped the extra $60 for the Hokas. 
          The Hokas do a good job of feeling lighter than they really are.  Just        looking at them, you would think they are heavy clodders.  Upon picking        them up they feel uber light.  Same thing happens when running in      them.  They have such a good bounce and energy return, that they seem          to shrug off some ounces and feel about the same weight as a pair of Pure Grits.
·        Cost.  These are the most expensive in my shoe quiver and gave me the most wife feedback.  But, if they last as long as I think, cost will be a mute point.  Plus, they do come with extra laces and another set of insoles allowing a more customizable fit.


Writer Bio
 
My name is Jason Robertson (33 years old).  I’ve been married for 15 years, have 3 kids and teach middle school Language Arts.
I grew up riding/racing dirt bikes and fell in love with running in ’09 after finally getting the right pair of shoes on my feet, ridding myself of shin splints, and completing my first 50k. 

Jason why so modest?  Jason has run over 20 Ultras, including 3 100 mile races.  Always up for a long run,  he is a constant source of inspiration and enthusiasm.